The Ming Report by Keith Hays

A WEEK IN THE BATTLE FOR IRAQI HEARTS AND MINDS

May 23, 2005 - Last week a senior American commander in Baghdad speaking “on background” expressed the opinion that while the US mission would be ultimately successful the effort would take years. Last week one more American soldier was convicted in the Abu Ghraib scandal. Last week the Army’s investigation of abuse and murder of Afghanis held at Bagram Air Base. Last Week international media mogul Rupert Murdock published degrading photographs of Saddam Hussein and others in US custody – photographs that could only come from the US military. Last week at least 13 American soldiers died in Iraq bringing the war’s death toll to at least 1634. And last week Operation Squeeze Play, the largest Iraqi – US joint operation to date - swept the Abu Ghraib district and detained an estimated 300 suspected rebels overnight. The commander of the US 10th Mountain division troops involved in the raid described the Iraqi forces as working well together and demonstrating good skills. It is the same kind of language that came out of the Saigon follies so many years ago. And finally this week the administration blamed Newsweek for anti-American demonstrations that cost 16 demonstrators their lives.

Somehow the outrages at Abu Ghraib reported in the Arab media long before the photographs surfaced had no role in fomenting anti-US sentiment. Somehow the torture and murders at Bagram Air Base, the details of which were well know on the streets of Kabul long before the New York Times got possession of a copy of the Army’s investigation, had no role in enflaming the mobs to riot. Somehow accounts of abuse and desecration of the Koran taken home to London, Afghanistan, and Pakistan by released detainees well and widely publicized last September did not incite the jihadists to action. Only the one line in the Newsweek article claiming that an unreleased investigatory report found one incident credible had the capacity to do that. Then we should not be surprised. It is an article of Neo-Con faith that the only reason that we lost in Vietnam was the reporting of the war by a left leaning press. No wonder, with the Iraqification program bogging down and the cost of the war in money, materiel and people going up, they are out to blame the press and not the policy for every thing that is wrong.

And things are wrong two years after Tommy Franks and the President announced mission accomplished. Don Rumsfeld’s detention and interrogation polices have put America on a par with the worst totalitarian regimes of the old cold war. We have seen nothing like since … well, since we loosened Vietnamese tongues by shoving them out the door at 3,000 feet. America’s humane moral high ground has again sunk into the moral swamp where the ends always justify the means. The way to Iraqi hearts and minds is not through the swamp.


Agree? Disagree? Just want to add your .02 worth?

    Click here to send your comments to Ming

Return to Home Page


© Copyright Keith Hays
All Rights Reserved